This would've been a good book if I was new to any of these ideas. They're sound & accessible principles for how to think about motivation in the workplace.
Shortcomings & unexpected side effects of extrinsic rewards
- Can crowd out intrinsic motivation
- Diminishes long term performance
- Can crush creativity
- Can crowd out good behavior
- Can encourage cheating
- Can become addictive
- Can foster short term thinking
Self determination theory
- Autonomy (Autonomy) - desire to direct our own lives
- Mastery (Competence) - get better at something that matters
- Purpose (Relatedness) - yearning for our work to be a part of something bigger
- Author seems to be deviating from relatedness/connection in research literature, which seems to be more about belonging and connection to other humans
Other topics covered
- Flow
- Growth vs. fixed mindset
- Grit
- Sawyer Effect
- From Mark Twain, any work can become play, any play can become work (getting boys to paint fence for him)
- Work consists of whatever a body is to do, and that Play consists of whatever a body is not obliged to do.
- obliged
- Consider paying people to leave - it’s cheaper in the long run - Amazon, Zappos
- To encourage autonomy: ask for the results, leave the how to them
Mastery
- Flow is a key component to reaching mastery. To achieve flow, need the Goldilocks zone.
- Mastery is a mindset - you see your abilities as infinitely improvable (growth mindset)
- Mastery is pain, demanding effort, grit, and deliberate practice
- Mastery is an asymptote - a mountain without a peak
Purpose
- A sense of purpose is achieved if we:
- Do something that matters
- Do it well
- Do it in the service of a cause larger than ourselves
- He who has a WHY can bear any HOW - Frankl, Nietzsche
- A soldier fights hard for a ribbon - Napoleon
If/then (extrinsic) rewards require people to forfeit autonomy and therefore lower intrinsic motivation to do something
- Offering to pay blood donors reduced the amount of donors by half
- Microsoft Encarta vs Wikipedia
- Giving kids a reward for drawing caused them to draw less
- Extrinsic rewards can be useful when the task is algorithmic.
- Pay should meet basic needs. Beyond that, it is a poor motivator for performance. Better to provide rewards then/that style which are praise, feedback and useful information - not financial.
Research shows that the secret to high performance isn’t our biological drive or our reward-and-punishment drive, but our third drive—our deep-seated desire to direct our own lives, to extend and expand our abilities, and to live a life of purpose.
The new approach to motivation has three essential elements: (1) Autonomy—the desire to direct our own lives; (2) Mastery—the urge to get better and better at something that matters; and (3) Purpose—the yearning to do what we do in the service of something larger than ourselves.
TO MOTIVATE PEOPLE:
- Ask for the results, leave the how to them
- Desired results, by when, why it’s important
- Make them feel like they’re contributing to something important, great
- Provide praise, feedback and useful info when managing
- Don’t offer financial rewards, offer rewards that encourage intrinsic motivation (feedback, useful info, praise)